Looking for torture doesn't work links, especially from US military - Input Junkie
Looking for torture doesn't work links, especially from US military|
It's looks like it's time to argue about this
I know there's a lot of good work online about it, including from pecunium
, but I don't have specific locations handy to memory.
Also, anything solid about the long term effects of torture which doesn't leave visible marks would be appreciated.Addendum:
Eric says (in comments) that he's against torture. However, he seems to define anything which doesn't leave marks as not being torture.
I'll be working on sorting this stuff out when I comment over there.
I'll let you sort through this, because I don't know exactly what you're looking for, but solarbird
regularly blogs about it and lumps the posts under her general politics tag
I'm actually surprised you don't read her already. Anyhoo, I hope this helps.
The piece I want to argue with is written from the assumption that the only reason anyone would have for opposing torture is wanting to get status with fellow upper class liberals. Sensible tough people who really want to protect America have the common sense point of view that torture is the only reliable method of getting information from our enemies.
I'm not sure how far I'll into ad hominem, but I do want to lay out some facts about the existence and effectiveness of the profession of civilized military interrogation.
|Date:||February 17th, 2010 09:28 pm (UTC)|| |
The piece I want to argue with is written from the assumption that the only reason anyone would have for opposing torture is wanting to get status with fellow upper class liberals.
The only reason Eric Raymond says about half the stuff that he says about politics is to piss off liberals anyway. Most of his political posts have a really obvious your outrage demonstrates how smart I am subtext. I think it's occasionally seeped up into the text, but I don't feel like wading through is archives to verify that.
|Date:||February 17th, 2010 05:31 pm (UTC)|| |
have not looked at links
but being subjucted to pain, esp random pain or psychological can leave long term scars. PTSD Night terrers more. Phobias
Having been subjected to the worst pain known to medical sicence for over 4 years Havng random electral shocks that could acure at any moment you have to understand you can live in constant fear of pain or freedom being taking away from you.
If you have been in a position of being icolated, torchered, unsuported, acused, it is enuff to break your soul.
|Date:||February 17th, 2010 05:42 pm (UTC)|| |
Why does it not surprise me that Raymond is a torture advocate?
I guess it shouldn't. Eric has a fondness (afaik only theoretical/emotional) for violent solutions, and a difficulty grasping that violent solutions (even by the people on your own side) may have undesirable side effects.
I'm working on an argument to the effect that good effects gotten from extreme level of consent in his beloved open-source movement should offer a clue that behaving as though people have minds is an option which should be considered more carefully.
Once again, I wish wilful ignorance in defiance of the facts was painful to the ignorant, rather than the rest of us. Reasoned argument will get you nowhere with that one. If he likes violent solutions, why not just hit him with a hammer till he stops blabbing?
I'm not sure anyone's immune to willful ignorance. As you say, it might be better for the human race if it were painful, but don't count on all the ignorance being on one side.
I don't know if I was behaving like it by linking to his blog, but Eric is a longterm friend of mine.
My thoughts on this are more complex than can be easily tapped out on an iPod when I should be translating Alcman.
It doesn't have to be responded to, but it's still around and, imho, still dangerous, and I'm in the mood to take a crack at it.
Thanks for the link.
There's a very good Fresh Air that talks with an interrogator--an actual interrogator, not a torturer.
|Date:||February 18th, 2010 02:42 am (UTC)|| |
Pecunium, referenced above, is also a (former?) military interrogator, who has written a great deal about exactly how badly torture works, at every level but especially at the level of "getting useful information in a timely manner", for which it is supposed to be a magic ticket.