I'd assumed that Etsy just sold crafts, and mostly had it mentally filed under "like used books, a market that ebay let get away", but it turns out that they also sell items over 20 years old.
The thing I can't figure out is whether etsy makes it possible for customers to offer recommended seller lists.
And just to save you guys from having to mention it, Regretsy is still running. It doesn't do much for me, but I appreciate their "Where DIY meets WTF" motto, and am amused that Twilight is their only highly specific category.
Addendum: jennythe_reader commented that etsy has a way for members to list their favorite shops.