I have comments in both places
I have comments at dreamwidth only
I've tried both approaches and I prefer comments at both sites
I've tried both approaches and I prefer comments at DW only
I have comments at both and have found that I've got distinctive commenting communities
There's another policy you haven't thought of
For the commenters
I don't care if I need to head over to DW to comment
I don't care if I need to head over to DW to check on a discussion
I'm less likely to comment if the comments are DW only
I'm doing this because the recent issue about a default link between LJ and Facebook strikes me as LJ showing lack of concern about its core function.
Any friendslocked posts will be DW only, but I'm curious about the effects of different comment policies for open posts.
'Twy' is a word from the Dorothy Sayers translation of the Divine Comedy-- the griffins are referred to as twy-colored beasts.
I wish Dreamwidth had chosen a different name because it's impossible to tell how to spell it from just hearing it. "Dreamwidth, like bandwidth" solves the problem but shouldn't be necessary