nancylebov (nancylebov) wrote,

Reading _A Dance with Dragons_

No spoilers, please-- I'm only(!) about 600 pages in.

This book strikes me as realistic in a very general sort of way-- history is crowded, with lots of people and nations bumping up against each other. Much as I love LOTR and the Riddlemaster Trilogy [1], those have the nations being much too distinct. Even Martin probably underestimates how much the various cultures would influence each other.

It also has a quality that I can only describe as atheistic-- it seems like a universe where no one is in charge. [2] It's not like The Golden Compass, which is more like an argument for atheism, or at least the badness of organized religion, or possibly the badness of organized religion which looks something like Catholicism. The thing is, if a book is making a strong argument for a single point, it isn't the same as book about a universe that just sort of thrashes along.

A minor nitpick: Martin consistently uses "wroth" when he means "wrath".

[1]I much prefer the first book.

[2]I was tempted to say "not even the author", but that seems unfair-- I'd been worried that Martin had lost track of overall story structure, but this book at least seems as though it's building towards something.

This entry was posted at Comments are welcome here or there. comment count unavailable comments so far on that entry.

  • HC 25-26, PB 16-17

    The man greets Awd Mally, who is something like a woman and something like a stone. "She had never spoken to him; she was not always there. Some said…

  • Moonwise: HC 23-24, PB 13-15

    There's a new section called 0:Hallows. The other sections are sequentially numbered with roman numerals. From The Word Hoard: Hallows: All Hallows…

  • Moonwise: HC 18-20, PB 11-13

    "One page was all a maze of umber sketches--hands, leaves, stones, strange leering faces--all in Sylvie's nervous line, at its heart, no right way…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded