nancylebov (nancylebov) wrote,
nancylebov
nancylebov

A sense of place

Having read Embassytown and Leviathan Wakes, I found that Leviathan Wakes made me crazy for the first two thirds or so-- it didn't seem to be set anywhere in particular, and the different locations all seemed the same. (The last third of the book picks up and I stopped caring about the lack of sense of place and the absence of distinctive voices for the characters. Sense of wonder for the win!)

By comparison, Embassytown wasn't vague.

However, neither of them gave a lot of sensory details about setting, so I'm not sure what made the difference for me. My tentative theory is that a sense of place can be given through sensory details (LOTR is a classic example), but a book can also be a place, and the prose in Embassytown-- that steady, focused narrator-- made it seem as though I was reading something in particular.

I don't know whether the way my sense of place works is unusual. Do you find there are books which give you a strong sense of place without having a lot of sensory detail?

Also, Embassytown struck me as very Delanyish-- not as sparkly, but with the strong interest in how language works, and with details of what's happening to people's status and involvement in different groups. Some reviewer found the book reminded them of Gene Wolfe, and I can't imagine why.

This entry was posted at http://nancylebov.dreamwidth.org/546222.html. Comments are welcome here or there. comment count unavailable comments so far on that entry.
Subscribe

  • Some Jewish Stuff

    And since these are essay questions, I'm not going to make you look things up. This is a core dump of things I've thought for a while, but I've been…

  • An odd encounter

    On Saturday, I did a little flea marketing, and one passerby asked my name. When I said "Nancy", she said, "What's your last name?" and when I said…

  • Remember _Shockwave Rider_?

    Apparently, Delphi pools can work pretty well as long as the people in them are autonomous, decentralized, and cognitively diverse. There are good…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 16 comments

  • Some Jewish Stuff

    And since these are essay questions, I'm not going to make you look things up. This is a core dump of things I've thought for a while, but I've been…

  • An odd encounter

    On Saturday, I did a little flea marketing, and one passerby asked my name. When I said "Nancy", she said, "What's your last name?" and when I said…

  • Remember _Shockwave Rider_?

    Apparently, Delphi pools can work pretty well as long as the people in them are autonomous, decentralized, and cognitively diverse. There are good…